State Representatives ask State Attorney General to intervene in federal healthcare legislation

Today Rep. Susan Lynn and I asked our state Attorney General to prepare to block the federal healthcare reform bill now pending in Congress. Below is the letter and the news release.



If this bill passes, our state will be forced to expand Medicaid by $1.4 BILLION dollars annually. As it stands today, the legislation is not written so that every state in the Union receives equal protection under the law. As you are probably aware, a U.S. Senator from Nebraska was able to get any future increases in his state's Medicaid program paid for in the current bill. That means people like you and me and all Tennesseans will be footing the bill for the people of Nebraska.









State Representatives ask State Attorney General to intervene in federal healthcare legislation


On Monday, State Representatives Susan Lynn (R-Lebanon) and Debra Young Maggart (R-Hendersonville) asked Tennessee State Attorney General Robert Cooper to prepare to take the appropriate legal action against the federal government in the event HR 3200, the controversial federal healthcare reform legislation, passes into law. The legislators requested this action in order to grant Tennessee relief from the unfunded mandate contained in the bill that Tennessee complies with the expansion of the federal Medicaid program.


The letter notes that under the bill Tennessee would be forced to expand the state’s Medicaid program potentially costing the citizens of the state $1.4 billion dollars in additional state taxpayer funds annually.


“Such an increase would place a great burden on the citizens of this state. It is clear by the wording of the legislation itself that not every state would face a similar and equal burden,” stated Rep. Debra Maggart.


Lynn explained that, “We see this as a violation of equal protection of the law, an affront to our sovereignty, and as a breach of the U.S. Constitution.”


Lynn and Maggart noted that the passage of this bill is imminent so it is important that the AG prepare now to take immediate action, and they referenced Governor Bredesen’s recent comment that “we can’t print money.” The great issue for the states is that states are not allowed to borrow money for operations expenses. “Obviously, this is something that many in Washington just don’t understand,” stated Lynn.








Attorney General Robert E. Cooper, Jr.

P.O. Box 20207

Nashville, TN 37202-0207




Dear General Cooper,




This letter is to formally request that you prepare to take the appropriate legal action against the federal government in the event HR 3200 passes into law. We request this action in order to grant Tennessee relief from the unfunded mandate contained in the bill requiring Tennessee to comply with the expansion of the federal Medicaid program.




Under this bill, Tennessee would be forced to expand our Medicaid program, potentially costing the citizens of this state $1.4 billion dollars in additional state taxpayer funds annually. Such an increase would place a great burden on the citizens of this state. It is clear by the wording of the legislation itself that not every state would face a similar and equal burden.




We see this as a violation of equal protection of the law, an affront to our sovereignty, and a breach of the U.S. Constitution.





The passage of this bill is imminent, and as Governor Bredesen has noted, "We can't print money." This bill would expand the program beyond the fiscal capacity of this state.




Thank you for your timely attention of this matter.




Most sincerely,




Susan Lynn

State Representative

District 57




Debra Young Maggart

State Representative

District 45